I hate head games. Most people do.
Head games happen when information needs to be shared but isn’t. Someone knows something that affects you, but they’re keeping it to themselves.
Maybe they don’t like something you’re doing, but instead of saying so, they cancel plans, avoid you, or act distant. You’re left wondering what’s wrong while they sit on information that could clear everything up.
The pattern is simple: they have something to say, they don’t say it, and you end up confused. You might even start blaming yourself, trying to figure out what you did wrong, when the real problem is that they won’t tell you what’s actually bothering them.
People avoid direct communication because they fear the consequences. They worry you’ll get angry, hurt, or reject them. So instead of risking an honest conversation, they create distance and leave you guessing.
That’s the head game: making you responsible for figuring out what they won’t tell you.
I used to do this constantly in my relationships. If something bothered me about my partner, I wouldn’t say it directly. I’d withdraw emotionally, give disapproving looks, or make subtle comments, hoping she’d figure it out.
I thought I was protecting the relationship by avoiding conflict. What I was actually doing was creating confusion and making her feel unsafe.
When you can’t be direct with someone, you’re not protecting them from upset. You’re protecting yourself from having to be vulnerable. You’re avoiding the discomfort of an honest conversation by making the other person live in uncertainty instead.
Direct communication feels risky because it is. When you tell someone something they might not want to hear, you’re opening yourself up to their reaction. They might get upset. They might disagree. They might even leave. Those are real possibilities, and they’re scary.
But when you avoid that risk, the problem doesn’t go away. It grows. The thing that bothered you last week still bothers you this week. The distance you created to avoid one difficult conversation becomes a permanent gap in the relationship. You think you’re keeping the peace, but you’re actually building resentment.
I learned this the hard way in my previous marriage. Every time I held back from saying what I really thought or felt, I created a small barrier between us. I told myself I was being considerate, that I didn’t want to upset her. The truth was I didn’t want to face the possibility that being honest might lead to conflict or rejection.
Those barriers added up. Over time, we stopped being able to reach each other. She never knew where she stood with me because I wouldn’t tell her. I’d be upset about something, and instead of explaining what was wrong, I’d just act cold and distant. She’d try to figure out what she’d done, and I’d let her guess rather than just saying what was on my mind.
That’s emotional abuse, by the way. Making someone responsible for figuring out why you’re upset when you won’t tell them is manipulation. It keeps them off balance and focused on trying to please you instead of being themselves.
When I finally started being direct in my current relationship, everything changed. If something bothers me, I say it. If I need something, I ask for it. If I’m upset, I explain why instead of expecting her to read my mind. It feels vulnerable every single time, but it’s also the only way to build real trust.
My wife told a friend once that she’d never heard me judge her. When she said that, I realized how different this relationship was from all my previous ones. The difference wasn’t that I’d become perfect or that she never did anything that bothered me. The difference was that I’d learned to be direct instead of playing games (I used to be passive-aggressive, trying to manipulate to get what I wanted instead of sharing what was truly on mind).
Being direct doesn’t mean being harsh. You can be honest and kind at the same time. You can say “This bothers me” without attacking someone’s character. You can express a need without making demands. The key is saying what’s true instead of hoping the other person will somehow figure it out.
Some people think being indirect is more polite. They believe that hinting at a problem is kinder than stating it outright. But there’s nothing kind about leaving someone in the dark. When you hint instead of speaking clearly, you’re making them do the work of decoding your message. You’re testing whether they care enough to figure out what you won’t say.
And tests like that damage relationships because they’re based on the assumption that if someone really loved you, they’d know what you need without you having to say it.
Nobody can read your mind. Even people who know you well can’t always tell what you’re thinking or feeling. Expecting them to figure it out without clear communication isn’t romantic or considerate – it’s unfair.
I used to believe that if my partner really loved me, she’d know what I needed. I thought having to explain myself meant she didn’t care enough to pay attention. That belief kept me stuck in a pattern of expecting her to change without ever telling her what I actually wanted.
When I finally started asking for what I needed, I discovered something surprising: she wanted to know. She’d been trying to figure out how to make me happy, but my indirect communication made it impossible.
Once I started being clear, she could actually respond to what I was asking for instead of guessing.
Direct communication requires courage because it means accepting that the other person might not give you what you want. When you hint at something, you can tell yourself they would have said yes if they’d understood. When you ask directly and they say no, you have to face that reality.
Facing reality is how you build a real relationship.
When you know where you stand with someone, you can make informed decisions about whether the relationship works for you. When you’re always guessing, you’re throwing darts in the dark.
Some people avoid direct communication because they’ve learned that expressing needs leads to punishment. Maybe they grew up in a home where asking for something meant being told they were selfish or demanding. Or maybe past partners responded to honesty with anger or withdrawal. Those experiences create real fear around being direct.
If that’s your situation, healing that fear is part of learning to communicate clearly. You might need to start small – expressing minor preferences before working up to bigger needs. Or perhaps you need to practice with people who feel safer before trying it with someone who matters more.
But eventually, being direct has to become your default.
Relationships can’t thrive on hints and implications. They need clear, honest communication about what’s working and what isn’t.
I have something to say but I don’t want to say it
When someone is being indirect with you, you can call it out gently. You can say, “I’m getting the sense that something’s bothering you, but I’m not sure what it is. Can you tell me directly?” That gives them permission to be honest and shows you’re willing to hear whatever they need to say.
If they still won’t be direct, that tells you something important about whether they’re capable of the kind of communication a healthy relationship requires.
Some people are so committed to avoiding conflict that they’ll sacrifice clarity and connection to maintain surface-level peace.
You can’t force someone to be direct if they’re determined to play games. But you can decide whether you’re willing to stay in a relationship where you’re constantly guessing what the other person thinks or feels.
I’m not willing to do that anymore. I’d rather have an uncomfortable conversation than live in uncertainty.
I’d rather know someone is upset with me and why than spend days wondering what I did wrong.
I’d rather risk conflict than sacrifice honesty.
That doesn’t mean every conversation is easy.
Sometimes being direct leads to arguments.
Sometimes the other person doesn’t like what I have to say.
And sometimes I have to sit with the discomfort of knowing I’ve upset someone by being honest.
But those moments pass. The discomfort of an honest conversation is temporary. The damage from months or years of indirect communication is much harder to repair.
When you’re direct, you give the other person a chance to respond to reality instead of their interpretation of your hints. You give them the information they need to make changes if they want to. You also give yourself the opportunity to find out whether this person can actually meet your needs.
And most importantly, you stop making yourself responsible for managing their emotions by hiding your own. And you also stop pretending everything is fine when it isn’t, which continues to build resentment by expecting them to read your mind.
Being direct is a gift to both people in a relationship. It creates clarity where there was confusion, builds trust by showing you’re willing to be vulnerable, and gives both people the information they need to decide whether the relationship is working.
I wish I’d learned this earlier and understood that avoiding difficult conversations wasn’t protecting my relationships – it was slowly destroying them. If I had only known that the temporary discomfort of honesty was so much better than the permanent damage of playing games, life would have been so much easier.
If you’re someone who tends to be indirect, start practicing directness in small ways. Tell someone when you’re upset instead of acting distant. Ask for what you need instead of hoping they’ll offer. Say no when you mean no instead of making excuses.
It will feel uncomfortable at first. You might worry you’re being too demanding or too sensitive or fear the other person’s reaction. But the more you practice, the more natural it becomes.
And if you’re on the receiving end of someone’s indirect communication, you can ask for clarity. You can say, “I need you to tell me directly what’s bothering you” instead of trying to guess. You can refuse to play the game of figuring out what they won’t say.
Relationships work better when both people commit to being direct. When you know you can say what’s on your mind without being punished for it, you can relax. When you trust that the other person will tell you if something’s wrong, you don’t have to constantly monitor their mood for signs of hidden upset.
That’s the relationship I have now. We both say what we mean and ask for what we need. And we both trust that if something’s wrong, the other person will bring it up instead of expecting us to figure it out.
It’s not perfect. We still have disagreements and still sometimes struggle to find the right words. But we don’t play games and don’t leave each other guessing. And especially, we don’t make each other responsible for information we’re withholding.
That clarity makes everything easier. When she’s quiet, I don’t have to wonder if she’s upset with me – I know she’ll tell me if she is. When I need something, I don’t have to hope she’ll notice – I just ask. When either of us is bothered by something, we talk about it instead of letting it fester.
This is what I want for you. I want you to experience the relief of knowing where you stand with someone and to feel the freedom of being able to say what’s on your mind without fear. Nourish relationships with honesty instead of poisoning them with guessing games.
Say what you mean.
Ask for what you need.
Tell people when something bothers you instead of expecting them to figure it out.
It won’t always be comfortable. But it will always be clearer. And clarity is what allows real connection to happen.
|
Paul Colaianni
Paul Colaianni is an Emotional Abuse Expert and Behavior and Relationship Specialist who has been analyzing complex relationship dynamics since 2010. As the creator of the Healed Being program and host of the top-rated Love and Abuse and The Overwhelmed Brain podcasts, with over 21 million downloads worldwide, he specializes in helping people recognize hidden manipulation, navigate emotionally abusive relationships, and empower themselves to make informed decisions.
|